Authored by Brian S. Mudge
In its first ruling on the scope of estoppel under 35 U.S.C. §315(e)(1) following a final IPR decision, the Board has denied institution of trial in a second IPR involving the same patent. The case, Dell, Inc. v. Electronics & Telecommunications Research Institute, IPR2015-00549 (PTAB March 26, 2015) (paper 10), involved an IPR brought in connection with U.S. patent no. 6,978,346. As a result of a final decision issued in a previously-instituted IPR involving the same patent, the PTAB determined that challenges to claims 1-3 and 5-8 of the ’346 patent were precluded under the estoppel provisions governing IPRs. In its ruling, the Board explained that the legislative history of the estoppel provisions suggests a broad interpretation of the scope of estoppel.